Hyperprolactinemia is a relatively frequent laboratory abnormality (30-80%) as a result of antipsychotics and a reason to reduce or stop them. We describe two youngsters with autism spectrum disorder whose hyperprolactinemia was based on a false-positive laboratory finding due to macroprolactin. The consequences were: unnecessary endocrinological evaluation including a brain MRI, and undesirable antipsychotic dose reduction. Thus, hyperprolactinemia can be due to a falsely elevated prolactin concentration. There should be an addition to the current guidelines in which a work-up for macroprolactin screening is included.