Home

Tvp19 11omslag kijk verder

Tijdschrift voor Psychiatrie 44 (2002) 9, 609 - 619

Review article

Effectiveness of psychotherapy for depressive disorder in primary care

D.J.F. van Schaik, H.W.J. van Marwijk, D.A.W.M. van der Windt, A.T.F. Beekman, M. de Haan, R. van Dyck

background Psychotherapy may be an alternative to drug treatment for depressive disorder in primary care.
aim To give a systematic review about the effectiveness of psychotherapy for depressive disorder in primary care.
method Randomised controlled trials were selected in which the effectiveness of psychotherapy was studied in primary care patients with depressive disorder, using Medline, Psychinfo, the Cochrane library and Embase. Effect differences were estimated according to the standardized mean difference. results Ten studies met the selection criteria. Overall (based upon five studies), psychotherapy applied in a primary care setting was slightly more effective than usual care by a primary care physician for patients with depressive disorder. In seven studies psychotherapy was as effective as farmacotherapy for primary care patients with a depressive disorder. In one study, psychotherapy was more effective than placebo therapy for primary care patients with major depression. In patients with minor depression or dysthymia there was no difference between psychotherapy and placebo (two studies).
conclusion Psychotherapy is a good alternative to drug treatment, also in primary care patients with depressive disorder. Further research is needed to show to what extent psychotherapy is a feasible option in primary care.

keywords depression, effectiveness, primary care, psychotherapy, systematic review